Summary of Experience as an academic

Intellectual capacity building in the field of heritage conservation in post-colonial India is challenged by the continuation of a colonial hangover based on Victorian paradigms. The dominance of this perception has led to a form of amnesia where gap between the inside mind and the outside world has inhibited our ability to comprehend culture as a dynamic living entity. The implication of this gap allows persistency of a monument-centric colonial approach to heritage protection and management and limits the mind in the recognition of many of the layers of the existing historical, geographical and anthropological information borne by our cultural resources. Under such circumstances education becomes the only tool through which the values inherent in Indian heritage can be ‘rediscovered’, mainstreamed and thereon protected for future generations.

The syllabus evolved by me is based on a holistic and integrated paradigm which aims to enable professionals to comprehend Indian Heritage as a complex resource and an embodiment of indigenous knowledge systems generated by the active engagement of a community with their context. The 2 year course is divided into four semesters where in the first three semesters students engage in theoretical and practical sessions where the former constitutes of lectures, workshops, seminars and laboratory while the latter is a studio exercise where the students can apply theoretical courses. In the fourth and final semester, students undertake thesis and dissertation/research paper of sites, preferable exploring areas where there is a lacunae in information and their work can enhance the understanding of the resource. Here their ability to transition from theory to practice is explored and are encouraged to take live projects, current heritage problem which would in turn become dossiers, develop sustainable protection and management systems or project which have given professionals a new focus for investigation.

The three semesters where the students expend their maximum hours has an under-pinning module – the ‘Philosophical Basis’ which forms the core/spine or framework of the syllabus for intellectual capacity building. This is a self-evolving module, and its dynamicity allows the syllabus to be flexible to accept and incorporate the changing skills or technical knowhow hence updating itself and equipping professions with new skills required by professionals to competently deliberate his/her duties.1

The Philosophical Basis has three modules namely, the Foundation Course, Architectural Knowledge Systems and New Paradigms where the first part focuses on “re-orientation” and laying down the base to build upon for the graduate programme; dwells on training the mind, second acquiring necessary skills and abilities, including those for communication to be able to express what the mind has learnt. The second architectural knowledge systems provide an alternative method to understand historical architecture, developed from Indian traditional practices utilised in acquiring knowledge. The last module familiarises students with the theoretical framework for heritage conservation hence exploring the link between theory and practice. Through the three courses, the thrust has been to enable students as professionals to interface with the different disciplines without compromising on needs of heritage, hence mainstreaming the discipline of comprehensive heritage conservation for India.

The module philosophical basis has “rediscovered” the world of India’s historical cities and cultural regions with all its architectural contents and the underlying knowledge systems that supported. The evidence of the complex and diverse historical cultural resource layers that under pin the ground reality where planning and development is active. It can be concluded that this proves the relevance for an interdisciplinary, integrated approach with holistic thinking. The experience with this module has transformed pedagogy and inspired the development of teaching method innovations for new learning.

The Philosophical Basis serves as a fundamental module of the syllabus 2002 framework which defines the other relational modules of ‘Redefinition of Heritage Resources, Theory and Parameters,Technical Structure-Fabric, and Conservation Management’ which also continue through the three semesters. In the third semester the scale of the resource is further elaborated, and the students are expected to be able to qualify the complex systems evident in our cultural regions and landscapes. To cover heritage resources in a comprehensive manner, the complexity is addressed through the “knowledge systems” approach that enables large categories of heritage entities of cities, landscapes and regions to be brought under scientific study* through the three semesters. Be it historic city sacred or secular, or water system they all lend themselves to inter-disciplinary approach and multilevel technical and management measures to cover National, State and Local jurisdictions with stakeholders and communities. Our findings also show some structural changes required to support the safeguard of this irreplaceable resource which still remains the USP for the country. The positive attitude at the official level will go a long way to streamline and mainstream living heritage protection and sustainable effective management.

To complement the needs of the heritage entities identified, the modules of Technical – Structure and Fabric and Conservation management familiarise student with tools that are present and those that need to be developed or improved upon to safeguard heritage today. Theory subjects conventionally followed the inherited colonial western way based on the “Descartian” paradigm for compartmental/ silo thinking. Right now, after the long experience in holistic and integrated interdisciplinary approaches it is poised for a big change. Evaluations and impacts are informed through the analysis of the modules Parameters.

The formulation, implementation and constant improvement to keep abreast with time has been my focus for the last 30 years of my engagement with the Department of Architectural Conservation of the School of Planning and Architecture. This department initiated as a part of the Urban Design course, became an independent Master`s degree course in 1992 and required a curriculum that is based on a holistic and integrated paradigm, tailored to respond to the dynamic Indian context.

Two major influences have shaped the course of this syllabus. First, the holistic approach initiated by Dr Kapila Vatsyayan and Dr Subash Chandra Malik, with my field experiences in different parts of the country which together concluded that Indian historic cities are an embodiment of knowledge systems potential to stimulate a Post-Independence School of thinking. This formed the crux of the syllabus: application through the Philosophical Basis module has been enabling conservation architects in India to construct a framework for heritage management. The continuous engagement through a holistic and integrated paradigm has also enabled exploring new disciplines which furthers the understanding of Indian heritage.

The syllabus has been in operation for 2 decades and has been modified in 2002 to expand its horizon including new disciplines like heritage economics, law and jurisprudence etc within its ambit.

  • 1. Where a new subject is adjudged essential it is introduced into the syllabus as a subject which in a specific module as either a lecture or a workshop or a seminar, depending on its scope of application and content. Subjects such as heritage law and jurisprudence, heritage economics etc have been introduced into the syllabus as full-fledged subjects recognising its relevance in heritage management today.

TWO YEARS MASTERS PROGRAMME IN ARCHITECTURAL CONSERVATION: M. ARCH (ARCHITECTURAL CONSERVATION), New Syllabus 2002

The Department of Architectural Conservation was established in 1986, first as a Centre and Masters Program began in 2008 at t the School of Planning and Architecture the first in the country) that offers a Post Graduate degree in Architectural Conservation in India. The programme has evolved considerably in the last decade and a half. The syllabus of 1994 was a major departure towards a holistic and integrated approach tailored to the Indian Heritage reality. This Syllabus of 2002 is a further development of the experiences, explorations and experiments since which has been made into comprehensive educational package for young architects to gain a Masters through the study of fascinating world of historical architecture of the country. This programme is only open to architects and is visualized as a graduate programme in within the larger domain of architecture and confining itself to historical architecture. Students are prepared for a career and opportunities to work in heritage areas, and skills and abilities developed in this academic programme also help to extend the scope of work for those interested in an architectural practice to contextual design in historic areas. The student will also be able to develop solely on the maintenance, protection and management needs of historical architecture and areas.

The academic programme has a holistic and integrated approach to architectural conservation education, which stimulates and encourages development of rigorous and innovative methodologies of intellectual inquiry into the multi-faceted field of conservation in India. This programme seeks to maintain equal emphasis on theoretical understanding of the conceptual and philosophical base, rigorous scientific inquiry into various heritage conservation issues and operationalisation of ideas into appropriate management and action covering aspects such as conservation intervention at all levels.

Only Integrated and holistic approaches lead to effective solutions for management challenges, especially with the addition of heritage resource within the existing developmental, spatial and resource sectors. It is only an integrated approach that can slowly bring about the inclusion of these new facets into mainstream development processes. The Masters Programme follows an integrated approach that has been developed for the specific situation and conditions of the Indian subcontinent. The methodological thrust enables the student to contribute in interdisciplinary processes and projects.

Architectural Heritage is defined as a resource, a cultural resource, an irreplaceable resource and a knowledge system. It is very different from natural resources that lend themselves to scientific methodology. Heritage resource poses a different challenge to bring it within effective management. Therefore, the definition of heritage in this programme assumes a comprehensive and inclusive meaning however the selective or monument centric is still a popular one. Heritage in this programme primarily refers to the expanse of “Indian historical architecture” and is the source of knowledge for the Masters programme.

Through the subject of historical architecture, the Masters Programme provides an all-round education for the young architect. The conservation professional is expected to be involved in pioneering work that will need the mental abilities as well as many and various skills. In addition, a competent level of ability in all forms of expressions to put their thoughts into action.

Teaching methods

  • Lectures
  • Seminars, discussions and presentations
  • Workshops
  • Laboratory work to supplement the other classes & site visits
  • Placement and hands-on experience
  • Research work in the form of paper writing, thesis and research paper

The Framework

The Masters Programme structure and contents is designed to address the needs of heritage resource in the times of rapid change and globalization. It is a time when “value” and “importance” of natural and cultural resources has been “realized” but skills, capabilities or responsibilities towards effective protection and management have yet to be developed. The Masters programme address the special requirements of the built heritage comprising historic buildings, sites, areas, cities and cultural landscapes, as well as larger sustainable conservation and development issues in a comprehensive manner. Focused on Indian Heritage needs and tailored for the same — is uncompromisingly heritage oriented, focusing centrally on the Indian context and addresses all aspects of conservation from theory to practice.

The challenges of conservation education are educating the heritage professional within the market driven world and the heritage in India still remains “to be rediscovered”. The course is therefore the framework has been structured to meet these challenges.

The modules that form the structure and framework enable the student to develop within a subject area and also understand the relationships among the various aspects of the course. It also initiates the student into a lifelong process of structured learning due to the holistic and integrated nature of the framework. This framework has been developed over the last decade and a half.

The Modules and Structure

The course is structured in the form of modules, which are further subdivided into the various subjects. Each module has a specific intent or theme related to conservation, which carries through the semesters. The subjects under each module are different to cover the entire range of aspects but the modules remain constant. Subjects in each semester the enlarges or deepens.

The name of modules and the relationships: The modules that support and the modules that represent the subject area.

Redefinition of Heritage Resource

Table 1: Diagramme of the Modules

MODULES

Subjects

  Semester I

Semester II 

Semester II 

Philosophical Basis

Foundation Course, Visual Communication

Architectural Knowledge Systems, Written and Oral Communication

New Paradigms

Redefinition of Heritage Resource

Natural and Designed Landscape, Inventory and Documentation Techniques

Historic cities and its Heritage Component, Quantitative survey Techniques

Cultural Regions and Landscape Qualitative Survey Techniques

Technical – Structure and Fabric

Introduction to Traditional Building System, Materials & & Deterioration Process, Chemistry of Traditional Materials

Conservation of Traditional Building Materials and Structure

Upgradation of Historic Buildings for contemporary use

Conservation Management

Quality Management of Historic Buildings and Sites

Integrated Heritage Management – ITUC

National Level Heritage Management Systems in India and Abroad

Theory and Parameters

History and theory of Conservation, urban planning, regional planning, Housing, transport planning, Archaeology

History theory and Criticism of Architecture – I, ecological planning, environmental planning, development planning, conservation planning, sociology and anthropology

History Theory and Criticism of Architecture – II, Heritage Economics, Heritage and Jurisprudence, Cultural Tourism, Museology

Module 1: Philosophical Basis

A conservation architect is technically trained to manage historic buildings, areas and complexes both big and small. This requires a sound judgment and appreciation of architectural quality. In a country where only a few “monuments” represent its entire heritage it is up to the conservation architect to develop the methodology. Through this demonstrate for correct decisions for management. This module Prepares a student Academically, Mentally, intellectually and philosophically to work professionally in the field of Architectural Conservation.

In the 2002 scheme this was the “foundation course” in the First Semester. There was urgent need to orient the students towards the world of Indian historical architecture which was complex but treated simplistically if not totally ignored.

The students need to develop a philosophical basis towards the subject of their specialization. The module has been expanded and new concepts/ ideas like integrated and interdisciplinary approaches and methodology have been added.

In this module while the first part trains the mind the second part imparts the essential skills and abilities required, so that what the mind learns can be expressed and communicated. For example, the student will be able to express complex thoughts through drawing, speaking and writing, vital for a sound professional, and also for the development of heritage profession in the future.

Module 2: Redefinition of Heritage

Historical architecture is an “authentic” document and evidence of its place, time and society. In the Syllabus 94 it was called “Rediscovery of Architecture” and was a part of the module with other subjects, but now it has been made into a full-fledged module. The emphasis now is confined to understanding, describing and analysing all categories of architectural heritage though the two years to make the “Great Indian heritage” familiar to the student. As conservation professionals we are interested in a very high level of quantitative and qualitative information that is “embodied” in heritage itself. This will help interpret historic buildings and traditions accurately and positively for their protection and management. All categories of Indian heritage fall within the scope from a building fragment to the intangible and cultural landscapes- a complete range. A comprehensive knowledge base of historical architecture is constructed through the application of “knowledge systems approach”.

The new comprehensive definition of architectural heritage anticipates a completely different approach and methodology towards heritage protection and management. With this definition historical architecture becomes part of the mainstream and inclusive and hence a part of people’s lives. It is no longer the preserve of few Government agencies. This definition of heritage will result in a comprehensive protection and management across the categories and across the country. It also implies a total shift n paradigm (a great change from existing notions).

Module 3: Parameters /Theory

Earlier “Parameters” was a major module. This was so because conservation was a relatively new subject which had to find “professional space” among many other fully developed subjects and areas such as planning, archaeology, commercial tourism, building industry. The subjects were studied as they had a great influence and negative impacts on heritage due to the underlying policies or processes that were existing. It is hoped that the study of the parameters will lead to the development of more sustainable approaches towards heritage resource.

In syllabus 2002 theory and parameters subjects have been combined. Originally, they were two modules but feedback from Director resulted in combing them. These inputs will and enhance quality of understanding of the influence and impacts of areas of governance on ground by other laws; the understanding gained will enable better management and subsequent action. The theory and parameters module comprises three types of subjects. First, those from the earlier parameters, second conventional theory disciplines such as sociology and anthropology that have been introduced to enhance understanding heritage resource in a holistic manner. Thirdly the new theory disciplines such as aspects of economics and Law have emerged as definite subjects for future development of interdisciplinary areas.

Module 4: Conservation Management

The module has been designed to have an integrated and holistic, participatory and decentralized approach for heritage management in India. Keeping in view the Indian reality of inadequate protection and management systems for heritage, the emphasis is on local community based “protection and management” of heritage resource. The module addresses all categories of heritage and responds to the needs of looking after heritage both for short and long term. Different levels of management from building and site i.e., ground level to National management systems and other areas such as heritage information Systems and risk Preparedness for heritage areas etc.

Module 5: Technical Conservation Actions on Structure and Fabric

This module remains the same, but the course has been expanded to make it more comprehensive. It has a laboratory component to supplement the Course. A four-week placement for hands on experience has been incorporated – a new addition.

Module 6: Architectural Conservation Studio

The studio exercise aims to handle the various scales of projects possible in conservation. It will be an application of the theory into practice.

  • First semester – Building or a small area Level project – study, reuse etc.
  • Second semester – Historic city & Area Level project
  • Third Semester – Cultural Landscape/ regions or a complex historic city with its hinterland
  • Fourth Semester – Thesis Project of Students Choice

The contents for the two year – 4 semester programme follow.